Warning: TD Go transaction limits?

You can file this story under "developing," but I want to immediately alert my readers to a potential problem using the TD Go Visa Buxx card I wrote about last week.

My Experience

When my TD Go card first arrived it was loaded with my initial load of $20 (after my US Bank experience I decided I'd play it safe with this product). After activating the card, I immediately loaded it with $1,000 and headed down to my friendly neighborhood Walmart to make a bill payment, which was successful.

Over the course of a few days I was able to load an additional $1,980, meeting the monthly load limit of $3,000 without exceeding the balance limit of $2,000 described in the TD Go product guide (link not currently working).

Today I went back to the same Walmart and tried to make a bill payment for $1,980, which should have been allowed since it's under the $2,000 published daily transaction limit.

The transaction failed, with the error "debit not allowed" printing out on a slip from the register. Remembering this FlyerTalk post, I feared the worst and immediately called the number on the back of the card.

I was immediately connected to a customer service representative, who saw the declined transaction and set about researching the problem. He said "the limits recently changed," but didn't know the details.

When he came back, he told me that there was a new $1,000 transaction limit, but that I could swipe my card once for $1,000 and then again for the balance of my purchase.

That didn't work either.

When I got home I hopped onto Evolve Money and initiated a $980 bill payment to a 529 College Savings Plan account, which processed successfully and was immediately reflected on my online TD Go balance.

One Hypothesis

At this point, based on the extremely limited data I have, my tentative hypothesis is that the $2,000 transaction limit described in the TD Go product guide is not actually a daily limit, but is rather enforced over some other period. My current purchases are on January 26 and 28, so if it's a 7-day rolling limit I should be able to make another transaction on February 2 or 3. Naturally I will keep my readers updated with that data.

The reason to tentatively suspect that it's a 7-day rolling limit is that is the time period for the Nationwide Visa Buxx's $800 transaction limit.

The worst case scenario is that the limit is enforced over a 30-day rolling period, in which case this card is functionally only good for $2,000 in cheap manufactured spend per month, rather than $3,000.

More Data Needed!

Do you have a TD Go card yet? Have you run into any transaction limits? Have any of your large purchases at Walmart been declined? See you in the comments.

Personal Finance Digest is a pretty good blog

I try to keep a pretty minimal list of RSS feed subscriptions. There's so much duplication between the most prominent blogs that I have my feeds winnowed down to the bloggers that are the best writers, since you only really need one or two subscriptions to be notified when new promotions are announced, signup bonuses change, and so on. Then on top of that I subscribe to Frequent Miler, for whom I have tremendous respect. Since I almost entirely refrain from the shopping-portal-gift-card-shopping-portal game, I only rarely take advantage of the ideas posted over there, but he'll often suggest new ways of looking at a problem to drive down costs or drive up yield.

However I'm always on the lookout for new blogs — and new ideas — and the other day I stumbled across Personal Finance Digest. I don't know pfdigest, although I think we've crossed paths on various forums and comments sections before.

It's not for everybody, but if you have some time I suggest heading over there and just casually scrolling through the first few pages of posts. The thing is, the posts are very dense, so it's not always immediately clear what's a potentially huge new opportunity and what's just odds and ends from around the internet. To help you get started, here's my curated list of recent posts that inspired me in one way or another:

  • A 75% bonus on Bank of America rewards for high-net-worth customers. I had some trouble pulling up the linked site; I found that to view the new program I need to open the link in an incognito window, say I was from Washington, and then open the link again (the new benefits are only available in Kansas, Missouri, Nevada, South Carolina, and Washington at the moment). Here's a little more detail from the terms and conditions of that offer:

Basically, with the Bank of America Cash Rewards card you end up with 1.75% cash back on all purchases, 3.5% at grocery stores, and 5.25% at gas stations (for the first $1,500 you spend in combined grocery store and gas purchases each quarter). Of course you could carry both the Cash Rewards card and the Travel Rewards card he discusses in that post to cover all your bases;

So that's what I've been reading lately. Did any of these ideas pique your curiosity? See you in the comments.

Virgin Atlantic devaluation got you down? Don't forget Hawaiian

My RSS reader blew up the other day with news that Virgin Atlantic had announced a change to their partnership with Hilton HHonors. Starting February 6, 2014, the transfer ratio will no longer be 2 HHonors points per 1 Flying Club mile, but instead 3 HHonors points per 2 Flying Club miles.

Now, I didn't exactly care that this ratio was changing, except to write a note to self for the next edition of my ebook, but then I realized that none of the bloggers were making the obvious point: the Hawaiian Airlines transfer ratio hasn't changed.

As I explained earlier, I stay at a lot of Hiltons and find the availability of their Cash and Points awards, which sometimes let me redeem my HHonors 0.4-0.6 cents each, to be quite good. Still, I would never redeem flexible Chase or American Express points, or Starpoints, for Virgin Atlantic miles in order to transfer them at a measly 1 : 2 ratio.

Still, if you are really gunning for HHonors points, this means that the Hawaiian Airlines credit card, with its 35,000 HawaiianMile signup bonus (and $89 annual fee) will still be worth 70,000 HHonors points after February 6, 2014, while the $90 Bank of America Virgin Atlantic WorldElite MasterCard would need to offer 46,667 miles to match that offer (my casual search found that the best current offer is for 20,000 Flying Club miles – leave a comment if you know of a better current offer).

Note: HawaiianMiles transferred into the program from Membership Rewards and Starwood Preferred Guest cannot be transferred into HHonors points; those earned with the credit card can be, presumably including miles earned through signup bonuses. For more discussion of this issue see this FlyerTalk thread.

Do this now: Hilton HHonors Spring Promotion

As you can see on my updated Hotel Promotions page, Hilton HHonors has announced a Spring promotion, whereby you can earn up to 9,000 HHonors points per paid stay between February 1, 2014 and April 30, 2014. You'll earn 1,000 HHonors points per paid Thursday, Friday, Saturday, or Sunday night stay, plus 5,000 HHonors points per 2-night stay that includes 2 or more of those nights. Register for the promotion here, and find the list of non-participating properties here.

Many bloggers have panned this promotion for not offering outsized rewards. Fair! I stay in a fair number of Hiltons because of their convenient downtown locations, HHonors points are relatively easy to earn with the no-annual-fee Hilton HHonors American Express or $75-annual-fee Surpass, and because as a Gold member I receive free breakfast for myself and anyone else staying in my room. So I consider it a decent possibility that I'll end up earning a few thousand points through this promotion, which is why I registered right away, before I forgot.

You should do the same.

Thank You, Blog Readers and American Heroes

I've always thought of this blog as a kind of collaborative project between me and my readers: I love sharing my new schemes and discoveries, and some of my best ideas have been contributed or inspired by readers. Today I want to continue opening the books on the project, and share with the curious some details on the support my readers have provided to the site.

Book Sales

It occasionally comes up in comments that I'm always trying to sell books.

I sure am!

Between the day the book first went on sale on Valentine's Day, February 14, 2013, and December 31, 2013:

  • 142 readers bought or borrowed the book through Amazon.com;
  • Another 118 people downloaded the book for free during the week-long promotional period I launched the book with;
  • I make about $2 per book that's purchased or borrowed, and earned a total of $263.44 from Amazon book sales in 2013.

Signup Links

While I don't have any credit card affiliate links here on the site, there are a few referral links scattered around, and I occasionally get a few dollars from those referrals:

  • Plink. 14 referrals; 100 Plink points, worth $1, per referral. $14.
  • Uber. 7 referrals (1 complete, 6 pending); $20 Uber credit per referral. $20 ($120 pending).
  • TopCashBack. 3 referrals; $10-15 per referral. $35.
  • Venmo. 1 referral; $1-5 per referral. $1.
  • BigCrumbs. 0 referrals.
  • Fat Wallet. 0 referrals.
  • Discover it. This is a "refer a friend" signup link for the Discover it card, which is also the only way to get the $50 signup bonus for the card (if you sign up for the card directly there's usually no bonus). 0 referrals.

PayPal Subscriptions

About a month ago, readers who visit the blog's website (rather than using an RSS reader or e-mail subscription) noticed that there was a new box in the righthand column, giving the option of signing up for a "PayPal subscription." As I explained last Friday, this is a way to continue supporting this project by making a small weekly or monthly contribution, if you feel like it's made a difference in your effectiveness playing the game.

  • PayPal Subscriptions: 1 (thanks for your support Ben!).

Conclusion

I don't have any terribly exciting conclusions to draw from this data:

  • This website is a labor of love, and my main reward is getting feedback from the amazing readers I've been able to help;
  • It means an incredible amount to me when readers buy the book, use my signup links, and of course signup for PayPal subscriptions to provide continuing support for the site;
  • Keep reading, keep writing comments, and keep the feedback and suggestions coming. The tips and tricks you guys suggest get multiplied through this site and help hundreds of people every day make or save thousands of dollars every year.

So here's to another year of travel hacks: new, old, and crazy! I do hope you'll stick around.

"What's the best credit card?"

I have a lot of family and friends who typically find themselves somewhere between amusement, shock, and awe when I talk about this crazy game we play. But sooner or later when they foresee a big upcoming expense, whether it's a wedding, a move, or a remodel, they come to me and ask, "Alright hotshot, you're the expert, what's the best credit card?"

After all, here I am, a starving artist trying to push books out the door and get people to pay for a blog they can read for free, but I take long weekends a few times a month and three or four long vacations each year – in first class, whenever possible. Nonetheless, my answer is almost always the same:

It doesn't really work like that.

Sure, I'll pass along a particularly good signup bonus, like the 55,000 mile Chase United MileagePlus Explorer offer I recommended to my Polish friend, or the 50,000 mile Citi Platinum Select / AAdvantage offer I signed up for earlier this month, since those bonuses are so high even a rookie is sure to get a good enough value that I'll be able to sleep at night.

One Question

Mile-and-point-earning credits cards are not right for everybody, and in fact they're right for almost nobody. When my brother recently asked what credit cards his friend should sign up for, the only question I asked was,

"Is she a businessman who is allowed to charge business travel to her personal credit card, and/or is she crazy?"

If the answer to both is no, a mile-and-point-earning credit card is not right for her.

One Size Fits All? Cash Back.

The best credit for the average civilian is the Fidelity Investment Rewards American Express card. It earns 2% cash back everywhere American Express is accepted, and has no annual fee. American Express isn't accepted everywhere, so our average civilian should carry a backup Visa, MasterCard, or Discover. I have both a Chase Freedom Visa and Discover it card, for example, and I'll be doing a product change to the Citi Dividend Platinum Select once I use up my ThankYou point balance from my current ThankYou Preferred card.

Even better, the rewards balance on Chase Freedom and Discover it cards can be used at their full value on Amazon.com purchases, so users can use their rewards immediately for online purchases, rather than waiting for them to accumulate. For example, Discover requires a $50 rewards balance to redeem for cash, the swine.

Foreign Transaction Fees

I would slightly lean towards the Discover it because it doesn't have a foreign transaction fee, so for the very occasional international trip the average user takes, that would provide some real savings. Discover cards are processed on the Diner's Club network, so they have quite good acceptance overseas, although somewhat less than Visa or MasterCard (and much better than American Express).

Of course a free Bluebird account also doesn't have foreign transaction fees, and can be used as an ATM card at many international ATMs, but does operate on the American Express card network so acceptance could be a problem depending on the destination.

The Exceptions

Of course, if you are a businessman who charges company expenses to your personal credit card, or you are crazy, travel hacking is an amazingly lucrative hobby that allows you to travel the world for pennies on the dollar. Buy my book! Read my blog! If you like it, consider setting up a monthly PayPal subscription! But when your friends ask, tell them the same thing I told my brother: a solid 2% cash back card is going to get them farther, faster, then messing around with co-branded credit cards that earn just one mile or point per dollar.

Travel bleg: where should I stay in New York City?

When I published my 2013 end-of-year report on my manufactured spend activity, one of the requests I got from some readers was for more information on how I spend my miles and points and not just how I earn them. I just booked a pretty involved itinerary for March that I'll be posting about once it's finalized, but I'm still struggling with the last piece of the puzzle: where should I stay in New York City?

I'm planning on a long weekend in the City, preferably from Thursday to Sunday, although Friday to Sunday is fine as well. Since I always keep a balance of Club Carlson Gold Points, I went ahead and booked a 2-night award stay at the Radisson Martinique on Broadway for 50,000 Gold Points, valuing that 2-night stay at $222, which seems like a good value for New York City. For comparison, the AAA rate would be $511.92 for the same stay.

To book the previous Thursday would cost another 50,000 Gold Points or $238, which I consider a push since the paid rate would also earn Gold Points.

My concern is that for some reason I have a bad impression of the Radisson Martinique. I've never stayed there, but whenever I read about it it's people saying things like:

"It’s such a so so hotel. There is no way for me to pay to stay there."

"I am not the biggest fan of this hotel...Truly NY-style matchbox size rooms."

So I'm curious if my readers have any great insights or little-known hacks for getting great values in Manhattan. I have all of my February statement cycles to go, so I could run up the score on my Chase Sapphire Preferred in order to transfer Ultimate Rewards points to Hyatt and stay at one of their properties for 20,000 or 25,000 Hyatt Gold Passport points, but it's tough to imagine that's going to be a better value than the Radisson Martinique.

Are there other properties or programs I should be looking at? Good best rate guarantee opportunities?

Welcome the newest member of the Buxx family: TD Go Card

January is the month that keeps on giving.

Flyertalk member and American Hero BarnyardRomeo on Monday brought the community's attention to the existence of a new member of the Visa Buxx family of prepaid cards: the TD Go Card. I ordered my card immediately, and while it hasn't arrived yet, I want to share what I know so those of my readers who are interested can get their orders in as soon as possible.

Background: Visa Buxx

The Visa Buxx family of cards are PIN-enabled, reloadable prepaid Visa debit cards. While there are a fair number of these cards, the two that have traditionally been of interest to the travel hacking community are the Nationwide Visa Buxx and US Bank Visa Buxx (and the similar, since-discontinued Wells Fargo Prepaid Card), since they can be reloaded using third-party Visa and MasterCard credit cards. Most – but not all – credit card companies award miles and points for these transactions, and the money can be easily liquidated using any of the PIN-based debit techniques we have available.

I wrote a whole post on the nuances of loading and unloading those two cards, so if you're hazy on the details of Visa Buxx cards, check out that post before reading on.

Signing Up

Like the Nationwide Visa Buxx – but unlike the US Bank card – it's possible to sign up for a TD Go card using the same personal information for the "parent" and the "teen." That means it's not necessary to fudge your data or "swap places" with a partner in order to register. I did leave my middle initial out in the "teen" information section, purely from an overabundance of caution.

You can make an initial load of $20 to $1,000 using any Visa or MasterCard credit or debit card, and you'll pay a $4.95 enrollment fee.

Limits

Here's where this card gets really exciting: it's superior to the Nationwide and Visa Buxx cards in every way. From the terms and conditions, here are the limits on loads:

Limitations on Dollar Amount of Loads. The initial minimum load is twenty dollars ($20.00) and the maximum is one thousand dollars ($1,000). You may load up to one thousand ($1,000.00) per day on Your Card, not to exceed three thousand dollars ($3,000.00) per thirty (30) days. Your maximum Card value at any time is two thousand dollars ($2,000.00).

Even better, instead of $2.50 (for the US Bank card) or $2 (for Nationwide), each load of up to $1,000 costs just $1.

Now, before you try to load $3,000 over three days and make a single Walmart bill payment, keep in mind that the maximum balance on the card at any one time is $2,000, and (not surprisingly) the card has a daily purchase limit of $2,000. You can find additional information in the terms and conditions and in this handy TD Go product guide. You should read both thoroughly.

Conclusion

I've already ordered my card, and I strongly recommend you think about ordering one for yourself as well. It's impossible to say how long this opportunity will last: the US Bank and Nationwide Visa Buxx are going strong with nary a whimper, while the highly-lucrative Well Fargo Prepaid Card was discontinued, presumably because it wasn't profitable enough for the issuing bank.

Here's hoping January has even more pleasant surprises in store for us!

Update: Evolve Money payments posting

[update 2/6/14: please see my post on Upromise Investments]

I'm happy to report that my first wave of Evolve Money payments made at the end of last week have all posted successfully to my online accounts. I added all the legitimate payees I could think of, as well as a few experiments along the lines of my "3 Insane Ways." Here are my results:

Bills

I was successfully able to make a payment to my Blue Cross Blue Shield dental insurance policy. Evolve Money promised to deliver it on January 21, but it apparently got there a little early:

I was also able to make an early payment to my gas provider, National Grid. Since same-day payments are free until February 16, I chose the "express" version of the payee – this is a different payee in the search function. Evolve Money claims to have delivered the payment on January 20 (a federal holiday), while National Grid posted the payment on the 21st:

Student Loans

I also made a student loan payment to "Federal Student Loans – All Servicers." Evolve Money claims to have delivered the money on January 21, and sure enough, there it is right on time:

529 College Savings Plans

Finally, I made 2 contributions to 529 College Savings Plans: one to my "real" 529 plan, with the Utah Educational Savings Program, and the second to a new account created with USAA. Both contributions posted right on schedule.

I haven't yet been able to determine whether the USAA plan will allow me to make electronic withdrawals from the 529 savings account like my UESP account does. It may take some trial and error to find an account that is compatible with Evolve Money and allows easy online withdrawals.

Preliminary Thoughts

In short, my first salvo of Evolve Money payments was an unqualified success. I also learned a few useful tips to make sure payments are processed correctly:

  • For payees with multiple addresses, use the billing address on your bill. This may seem like a no-brainer, but it was relevant in the cases of my student loan and utility bill payments. I was given a number of options for which address to send the payments to, and I selected the payee with the same mailing address, even though the biller name did not match. In the case of my student loans, my loan servicer is "FedLoan Servicing" They apparently share an address with another student loan servicer, and I made my (successful) payment to that servicer instead. Even though the names didn't match, the addresses did.
  • For all the payees I used, I was able to add the bill successfully by deleting any dashes or spaces in my account numbers.

My remaining unanswered question is whether the transactions I funded using my PayPal Business Debit MasterCard will earn 1% cash back. I'm extremely confident they will, since they are processed as signature transactions, but PayPal has not yet updated my pending cash back so I can't say so with certainty yet. Whether or not that 1% cash back option exists will determine what is the best funding source for these payments: PayPal, reloadable prepaid debit cards like Visa Buxx or MyVanilla Debit cards, or one-off gift cards purchased at drug stores, grocery stores, gas stations, or office supply stores with cards that bonus purchases at those merchants.

Like this post? Consider subscribing!

Connecting the dots: Chase Ink Visas back on top

[update 2/6/14: please see my post on Upromise Investments]

I mentioned a few months ago that I was planning to finally get a Chase Ink Bold card, which would allow me to earn bonus points at local convenience store locations categorized by Visa as gas stations.

Ultimately that plan was short-circuited in my impromptu January application cycle, when I jumped on a 100,000 Avios offer from the Chase British Airways Visa card.

I've had a tortured relationship with the Chase Ink Bold card: in principle, its earning rate at gas stations (2 Ultimate Rewards points per dollar) and office supply stores (5 Ultimate Rewards points per dollar) should make it one of the most lucrative cards available. In practice, every time I think I have a new source of gas station reload cards and gift cards, it's slammed shut by a register re-coding or employee re-training.

Meanwhile, while $200 Visa gift cards from office supply stores, with an activation fee of $6.95, allow you to buy Ultimate Rewards points at a cost of 0.67 cents each, liquidating those cards has traditionally required either using up valuable Bluebird reload space or buying inefficiently small money orders and bill payments.

Finally, since the United devaluation it's become increasing difficult to value Ultimate Rewards points at the 1.89 cents necessary to justify buying them for 0.67 cents each when you can buy Barclaycard Arrival miles, worth 1.11 cents, for just 0.39 cents each. (Explanation: 1.89 / 1.11 = 0.67 / 0.39).

Events have conspired to change that calculation, and again make the Chase Ink Bold Visa one of the most unimaginably lucrative cards on the market today.

Visa Savings Edge

Visa Savings Edge is a program that allows you to earn cash back in the form of statement credits on your account whenever you make eligible purchases at participating merchants. As Frequent Miler pointed out yesterday, Staples is one of those participating merchants. The offer reads:

Save 1% when you make a qualifying purchase of $200 or more with your enrolled Visa Business card in store or on staples.com. Save on thousands of products for your small business at Staples. From coffee to cleaning supplies and technology to business services, you’ll find everything you need to keep your business running. Now get 1% back via statement credit on all purchases at Staples® when you use your enrolled Visa® Business Card.

That means a $200 Visa gift card, rather than costing $6.95, will cost just $4.88, bringing the break-even value of Ultimate Rewards points down to 1.35.

Plink

Of course, as I mentioned yesterday in my trip report, Staples also participates in Plink, allowing you to earn $3 in Amazon credit every time you spend $60 or more at Staples. If you consider Amazon credit "as good as cash," you'll end up paying just $1.88 each time you buy a $200 Visa gift card – just 0.18 cents per Ultimate Reward point (up to 10 purchases per 30 days, per the terms of the Plink offer).

Liquidate Using Evolve Money

Finally, the last concern above, that liquidating $200 Visa gift cards is awkward, inefficient, and impractical, has been put to rest by the vast liquidation capacity of Evolve Money. If you take advantage only of the most lucrative version of this deal, combining both Visa Savings Edge and Plink, you'll have just $2,000 in gift cards to liquidate every 30 days. Since Evolve Money has plenty of legitimate payees, like utilities, insurance companies, phone companies, etc., $2,000 seems like an eminently reasonable amount to push through each month – especially when buying those gift cards is this unbelievably lucrative.

Honorable Mention: Club Carlson Business Rewards Visa

While the card itself doesn't bonus office supply store purchases, the Club Carlson Business Rewards Visa does earn 5 Club Carlson Gold Points on all purchases, which I've argued can in some cases be worth up to 1 cent each. The card can likewise be registered through Visa Savings Edge and through Plink, allowing you to pay the same 0.18 cents per point as with the Chase Ink cards.